Connect with us
Sunday,31-May-2026
Breaking News

Maharashtra

‘Standing Near Local Train Door Not Negligence,’ Says Bombay HC, Orders ₹4 Lakh Compensation In Mumbai Train Fall Death Case

Published

on

Mumbai, April 4: In a significant ruling on commuter safety, the Bombay High Court has held that standing near the door of a Mumbai local train cannot be treated as negligence, given the realities of overcrowding, and termed a man’s death after falling from a moving train as an “untoward incident” entitling his family to compensation.

High Court overturns tribunal decision

Justice Jitendra Jain, on April 2, allowed an appeal filed by Ashrappa Yellappa Bhandari and Satyamma Ashrappa Bhandari, challenging the Railway Claims Tribunal’s 2019 decision that had denied them compensation for the death of their kin, Balkrishna Bhandari.

Bhandari, a salesman, died on January 29, 2012, while travelling from Kalyan to Dombivli. He fell from a moving train between Thakurli and Dombivli stations. His family’s claim was rejected by the Tribunal on the ground that the incident did not qualify as an “untoward incident” under the Railways Act, 1989.

Court notes inconsistencies in official reports

The High Court, however, found inconsistencies in official reports. While some reports suggested that Bhandari was standing at the edge of the platform and was knocked down by a train, others stated that he fell from a moving train. Noting that there was no eyewitness to the incident, the court said it could not rely conclusively on any one version.

“I fail to understand how these authorities gave contradictory reports, moreso, when there is no eyewitness to the incident,” Justice Jain observed.

Benefit of doubt must favour victim

The court held that in cases involving welfare legislation and conflicting evidence, the benefit of doubt must go to the victim. “This Court has no option but to accept that the deceased died by falling down from a moving train, which constitutes ‘untoward incident’,” the judge said.

Ground realities of Mumbai local trains highlighted

Significantly, the court underscored the ground realities of Mumbai’s suburban rail network. “In Mumbai local, seldom are the seats vacant… even at starting point, people have to jump to occupy seat. Therefore, standing near the door cannot be treated as negligence,” the order noted.

Even if the version that Bhandari was standing near the platform edge were accepted, the court said, the incident would still qualify for compensation.

Safety concerns and need for civic awareness

The court also flagged safety gaps at railway platforms, pointing out that the yellow safety line is often faded and lacks clear communication of its purpose.

It suggested regular repainting and even the use of red markings to indicate danger zones. Authorities should also ensure announcements and enforcement to keep passengers behind safety lines, it said.

Calling for behavioural change, the court remarked, “There is a need to inculcate civic sense amongst ourselves like civic sense amongst Japanese people.”

Compensation awarded to family

Allowing the appeal, the court directed the Railways to pay compensation of Rs 4 lakh with 6% annual interest from the date of the accident, subject to a cap of Rs 8 lakh, to be equally shared by the two claimants within 12 weeks.

Crime

Mumbai: Irfan Edenwala arrested on charges of fraud and preparing fake documents, including under the Arms Act

Published

on

CRIME

Mumbai; The Mumbai Police has claimed to have arrested a youth who had cheated the police and administration by producing fake licenses and clearance certificates and had obtained fake police clearance certificates on Nagaland license. At Khar Police Station, Mumbai, a person named Faiz Irfan Edenwala, aged 36, illegally renewed his arms license from Nagaland using fake police clearance certificates and illegally kept firearms on the said arms license. He has also not submitted information about the said firearms in his possession to the Mumbai Police Commissionerate. Therefore, a case has been registered against him at Khar Police Station under sections 465, 467, 471, 474 IPC as well as sections 3, 25(1) (a), 30 of the Arms Act, 1959.

The accused named Faiz Irfan was arrested in the said crime on today as the investigation revealed that he was directly involved in the crime.

The said arrested accused was produced in the 9th Court, Bandra (East), Mumbai on May 30 and the Hon’ble Court remanded the said accused in police custody till June 2. Further investigation into the said crime is underway.

Continue Reading

Maharashtra

Eviction action against around 250 unauthorized structures in Powai’s Phuket Nagar and Malind Nagar areas

Published

on

A joint eviction operation was carried out by the ‘S’ Administrative Division (Ward) and the Water Engineering Department of the Mumbai Municipal Corporation on about 250 unauthorized structures on the land of the Water Engineering Department located in the Phuket Nagar and Malind Nagar areas of Powai. This operation was conducted under the guidance of Deputy Commissioner (Zone 6) Shinus Kumar Dhunde. and led by Assistant Commissioner Samiti. Samreen Sayyad was also present. The operation was taken after observing a large number of unauthorized structures on government land in the said area. This campaign is being implemented in a planned manner with the aim of clearing the concerned land from encroachments and protecting it. About 150 police personnel, around 50 engineering officers and employees of the ‘S’ Department and Water Engineers Department and 200 labourers were deployed for this operation. This operation was also carried out with the help of 7 JCBs, 10 dumpers and other small cargo vehicles. During the operation, the unauthorized structures are being removed and the area is being completely cleared. As soon as the process of removing encroachments is completed, the work of fencing the relevant area will also be started immediately and necessary security measures are being taken to prevent further encroachments. Meanwhile, the administration has clarified that action against encroachments on government and municipal-owned areas will continue regularly.

Continue Reading

Maharashtra

Mumbai Municipal Corporation has given three months to the concerned agencies to improve the quality of facilities provided in public toilets.

Published

on

The Mumbai Municipal Corporation is always ready to provide clean, safe and dignified public toilet facilities to the citizens. It has been found that these facilities are lacking in some places in North Mumbai. Therefore, the organizations operating public toilets on the ‘pay and use’ principle have been given a deadline of three months to improve the quality of the facilities. It has been warned that action will be taken against the organizations that do not improve within the stipulated period. In line with the vision of Union Minister for Commerce and Industry and MP from North Mumbai Piyush Goyal for clean, safe and citizen-friendly public toilets, a review meeting of the organizations operating ‘pay and use’ public toilets in North Mumbai was held today (30th May, 2026) at the Zone 7 office. The meeting was chaired by Ganesh Khankar, Leader of the House, Mumbai Municipal Corporation. The meeting was attended by Deputy Commissioner (Solid Waste Management) Kiran Dighavkar, Deputy Commissioner (Zone 7) Manish Valenju, Corporator Siddhant Sharma, Assistant Commissioner (R South), Assistant Commissioner (R Central) Praful Tambe, officers of the Solid Waste Management and Maintenance Department as well as representatives of organizations operating various public toilets were also present.

It has been observed that there is a need for improvement in the basic amenities, cleanliness and maintenance of public toilets. Leader of the House

Ganesh Khankar expressed the view that such public toilets need to be improved immediately.
All toilet operators were directed to complete the work of replacing broken commodes, fittings and other equipment, repairing broken doors and windows, repairing damaged tiles and cladding, painting and beautification in the next three months and bring necessary improvements in the standards of cleanliness and maintenance.

In addition, it has been made mandatory to implement a citizen feedback system in all public toilets, maintain a record of cleaning every hour, conduct a deep cleaning campaign at least once a week and install an IoT-based odor monitoring system to control odor. Assistant Commissioners of the concerned departments have been directed to issue notices to all institutions and regularly review the improvement work. It was also clarified in the meeting that the contracts of institutions that do not bring the expected improvements within a period of three months will be suspended or cancelled and alternative institutions will be appointed in their place.

The Leader of the House said that this campaign is being run with the aim of improving the quality of public toilets and providing citizens with cleaner, safer, and more dignified facilities.

Continue Reading
Advertisement
Advertisement

Trending