Connect with us
Friday,20-November-2026
Breaking News

Politics

Shiv Sena Case Is Before SC’s 7-Judge Bench Today

Published

on

A seven-judge Bench of the Supreme Court will today hear the 2022 case of Shiv Sena leader Subhash Desai versus Principal Secretary of the then Maharashtra Governor on whether issuing a notice seeking the removal of the Speaker restrains him from adjudicating disqualification petitions under the Tenth Schedule of the Constitution.

Bench to also hear Nabam Rebia vs Deputy Speaker case

The Bench, led by Chief Justice of India (CJI) DY Chandrachud, will also reconsider its 2016 decision in the Nabam Rebia vs Deputy Speaker case, which will have a significant bearing on the political crisis that led to the ouster of then Chief Minister Uddhav Thackeray. The case pertains to the political crisis that began in June 2022, when current Chief Minister Eknath S. Shinde and a large number of MLAs from the Shiv Sena rebelled against then Chief Minister Uddhav Thackeray in the Maharashtra Vidhan Sabha, leading to the collapse of the Maha Vikas Aghadi (MVA) government, comprising the Shiv Sena, the Nationalist Congress Party and the Indian National Congress.

Subhash Desai, the then general secretary of the Thackeray-led Shiv Sena, filed a petition challenging the governor’s invitation to Shinde to form the government.

On August 23, 2022, a three-judge bench of the Supreme Court comprising then CJI NV Ramana and Justices Krishna Murari and Hima Kohli observed that the matter raised important constitutional questions on the interpretation of the Tenth Schedule of the Constitution (Anti-Defection law) and referred it to a five-judge bench.

10 questions on power of speaker

The bench formulated ten questions in the reference order pertaining to the power of the Speaker or the Deputy Speaker to initiate disqualification proceedings while proceedings on their removal are pending. It also referred to the five-judge Constitution Bench ruling in the Nabam Rebia vs Deputy Speaker (2016) case, wherein it was held that the Speaker of a House cannot decide a disqualification petition filed under the antidefection law while a notice under Article 179(c) for his removal is pending.

However, on May 11, 2023, a five judge bench comprising CJI Chandrachud and Justices Hima Kohli, MR Shah, Krishna Murari, and PS Narasimha unanimously decided to refer the Nabam Rebia ruling to a seven-judge bench. The bench, which held that a substantial question of law remains to be settled, also took into account the conflict between the Nabam Rebia judgment and another five judge bench ruling in Kihoto Hollohan v. Zachillhu & Ors (1992) with regard to the scope of judicial interference in disqualification proceedings against a Speaker at an interlocutory stage.

National News

PM Modi speaks to CM Yogi; Amit Shah, Rajnath Singh condole his mother demise

Published

on

Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Friday spoke with Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath and expressed his condolences over the demise of his mother, Savitri Devi.

Union Home Minister Amit Shah and Defence Minister Rajnath Singh also expressed their grief over the passing of Savitri Devi and extended their condolences to the bereaved family.

Taking to the social media platform X, Amit Shah said, “The passing of Smt. Savitri Devi Ji, the mother of Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath Ji, is deeply saddening. A mother’s passing is a loss in life that can never be made up for. In this hour of grief, my condolences are with Yogi Ji and the entire bereaved family. I pray to God to grant the departed soul a place at His divine feet and give the grieving family the strength to bear this immense sorrow.”

Rajnath Singh also expressed his condolences, saying, “I was saddened to hear of the passing of Smt. Savitri Devi Ji, the revered mother of Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath Ji. The loss of a mother’s sheltering presence at any stage of life is the greatest and most unbearable blow. At this time of grief, my condolences are with Yogi Ji and the entire family. I pray to God to grant this virtuous soul a place at His divine feet.”

Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath’s mother, Savitri Devi, passed away at the age of 91 on Friday at her ancestral village of Panchur in Uttarakhand’s Pauri Garhwal district.

She breathed her last at around 11 a.m. on Friday, leaving the family in deep mourning.

According to reports, her last rites will be performed in Haridwar on Saturday.

The news of her demise prompted condolences from several political leaders, who expressed grief over the loss and extended their sympathies to the bereaved family.

Continue Reading

National News

Siraj not selected in India XI because of his name, says Cong MP; BJP calls remark ‘hateful’

Published

on

Congress MP Imran Masood, on Friday, claimed that cricketer Mohammed Siraj was not selected in India’s playing XI in the first Test match against New Zealand, because of his identity and religion, even as the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) referred to the remark as “hateful”.

Speaking to media, Masood expressed disappointment over Siraj not being included in the squad despite being in good form.

“His name is Siraj – isn’t that reason enough? If he is performing and still not getting selected, what else could be the reason? This alone can be the reason; there can be no other reason besides this,” the Congress leader claimed.

Former Uttar Pradesh Congress President Ajay Rai backed Masood, while blaming the BJP and RSS for “dividing society”.

“Ever since the Bharatiya Janata Party came to power and began governing, RSS members have been working to divide society. Sports foster emotions of unity, and when players compete in the true spirit of sportsmanship, there is no caste, community, class or religion; everybody plays together for the sake of the country,” he told media.

However, Congress leader Hussain Dalwai disapproved of Masood’s opinion.

He said: “I don’t think so – this is the kind of thing that happens in cricket… Looking at every single matter through that same lens is completely wrong.”

Meanwhile, the BJP expressed displeasure at Imran Masood’s remark, calling it “hateful”.

Madhya Pradesh Minister Vishwas Sarang remarked, “The minds of Congress leaders are filled with filth. Imran Masood’s statement is hateful. I feel ashamed that Congress has such leaders.”

He questioned Masood for bringing religion into sports, saying: “You are forgetting that this country has had many leaders and many players from the Muslim community, whom the people of this country have held in high regard. Merit matters here, not religion or caste, Imran Masood. If you make such divisive statements, it will not be tolerated. Bringing politics and religious issues into sports in this manner is a hateful act.”

BJP spokesperson T.R. Sriniwas echoed a similar view, asking, “Mr Imran Masood, are you jobless politically?”

“You don’t have any other thing like your Congress leader, Mr Rahul Gandhi? You accuse the BJP of doing Hindu-Muslim. What are you doing? You being from a minority community, at least talk sense about how to develop your community in terms of education and economic parity, as compared with other communities,” he told media.

“Instead of doing this and talking about good governance, you say, he (Siraj) is excluded for being from the Muslim community. This is not the way an MP should behave,” he stated.

Continue Reading

National News

Delhi residence cannot confer jurisdiction to de-index Assam court order: HC

Published

on

The Delhi High Court has dismissed a doctor’s plea seeking directions to Google and legal database Indian Kanoon to remove a 2019 bail order from name-based online search results, holding that his mere residence in Delhi or the accessibility of the judicial record online within the national capital cannot confer territorial jurisdiction on the court.

A single-judge Bench of Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma ruled that since the FIR, arrest, bail proceedings, filing of the chargesheet, and eventual discharge of the petitioner had all taken place in Assam, the Gauhati High Court would be the appropriate forum to examine his grievance.

The petitioner, a practising doctor, had approached the Delhi High Court seeking directions to Google and Indian Kanoon to de-index a bail order passed by the Gauhati High Court on September 27, 2019, from name-based search results and disable name-based search functionality in respect of the judicial record.

He submitted that although he had subsequently been discharged from the criminal case by a Judicial Magistrate in Assam on January 8, 2021, the bail order continued to appear when his name was searched on Google, adversely affecting his reputation and professional standing.

The petitioner contended that the discharge order had attained finality and that he was entitled to relief under the right to informational privacy guaranteed under Article 21 of the Constitution. However, the respondents raised a preliminary objection, questioning the territorial jurisdiction of the Delhi High Court on the ground that the entire criminal proceedings had taken place in Assam and the judicial order sought to be de-indexed had been passed by the Gauhati High Court.

Upholding the objection, Justice Sharma observed that the petitioner’s residence in Delhi was not a material or integral part of the cause of action and could not, by itself, confer territorial jurisdiction on the court.

The Delhi High Court said that the registration of the FIR in Assam, the passing of the bail order by the Gauhati High Court, the filing of the chargesheet and the subsequent discharge of the petitioner by the trial court were the material facts forming the basis of his claim. “The judicial record in question is the record of the High Court of Gauhati, and the record of the underlying criminal proceedings, which would be germane to determine the petitioner’s entitlement to the relief sought, is also situated in Assam,” the judgment said.

Rejecting the argument that the availability of the bail order through Google and Indian Kanoon in Delhi gave rise to a part of the cause of action, Justice Sharma observed that judicial records uploaded on the internet are accessible across the country and even globally.

“If the mere accessibility of a digitised judicial record at a particular place were to be treated as an integral part of the cause of action, every High Court in the country would possess the jurisdiction to entertain a petition seeking de-indexing of a judicial record of any other Court,” the judge said.

The judgment cautioned that accepting such an interpretation would render the territorial jurisdiction requirement under Article 226(2) of the Constitution meaningless and encourage forum shopping.

Invoking the doctrine of forum conveniens, the Delhi High Court held that the Gauhati High Court was the more appropriate forum to adjudicate the dispute, as any direction regulating access to or searchability of a judicial record passed by that court would be most appropriately examined by it.

It also observed that entertaining the petition could result in the same judicial record being considered by two different High Courts, creating the possibility of overlapping or conflicting directions.

“Any direction which would regulate the manner in which a judicial record of that Court is accessed or searched would, in the considered opinion of this Court, be most appropriately examined by that Court itself,” the judgment said.

The Delhi High Court dismissed the petition along with pending applications on the ground of lack of territorial jurisdiction, while leaving it open to the petitioner to pursue remedies available under law, including approaching the Gauhati High Court.

It clarified that its observations would not amount to an expression of opinion on the merits of the doctor’s claim for de-indexing.

Continue Reading

Trending