Connect with us
Friday,20-November-2026
Breaking News

Maharashtra

Mumbai News: Central Railway’s Sector-Wise Local Train Proposal Sparks Outrage Among Commuters; Officials Call It ‘Impractical’

Published

on

Mumbai: A controversial proposal by the Central Railway’s (CR) Mumbai division to overhaul the suburban railway system by segregating it into sector-wise corridors—akin to metro train operations—has ignited widespread backlash from commuters and railway officials alike.

Originally presented to the Railway Minister last year, the proposal aims to increase suburban train frequency to one every three minutes during peak hours by dividing the existing network into eight operational corridors.

These would include routes such as CSMT-Thane (slow), Thane-Kalyan (slow), Kalyan-Kasara (slow), CSMT-Kalyan (fast), CSMT-Panvel (slow), Belapur-Uran (slow), and Thane-Nerul/Vashi (slow), among others.

Although the presentation claims that this move could transform Mumbai’s local train operations, a fierce debate has erupted over the practicality of the leaked proposal.

“This proposal is unadulterated absurdity. The person who prepared it has no idea about Mumbai and has clearly never used the Mumbai suburban network as a means of transport for work,” said former General Manager of Central Railway, Subodh Jain

According to a senior CR official, who declined to be named, “The plan may look good on paper, but in reality, it’s completely impractical. It would involve mass transhipment of passengers at busy junctions like Thane and Kalyan—already under tremendous pressure.”

“Catching one train itself is a big hassle—now imagine the inconvenience of changing 3 to 4 trains in a single journey and the extra time lost at each station,” said a senior Central Railway officer.

“The crowding at transhipment stations will be unimaginable. Passengers who manage to get a seat in the first train will likely lose it in the connecting train, as those already standing will rush to board first.”

The elaborate plan (FPJ has a copy) involves running services sector-wise — with the first sector operating only between CSMT and Thane on the slow line, the second sector covering CSMT to Kalyan on the fast line, and the third sector managing operations between Thane and Kalyan on the slow corridor, as well as Kalyan to Kasara and Kalyan to Karjat.

While the presentation made by the Mumbai Division under the leadership of the then Divisional Railway Manager, Rajnish Goyal, claims that sector-wise operations could boost efficiency and frequency, even internal voices remain skeptical.

The concerns are not just logistical but also practical—crowding at transhipment points, loss of seating priority, added travel time, and passenger confusion could worsen the already strained infrastructure.

Sources within CR have hinted that the proposal may have been “deliberately leaked” this week, rekindling both internal debates and public scrutiny.

Passengers, who form the backbone of Mumbai’s lifeline, expressed their frustration across social media platforms and in interviews.

Jayant Sathe, a daily commuter from Kalyan, remarked, “Whoever designed this plan clearly doesn’t understand Mumbai’s suburban travel. Changing trains at Thane after boarding from Badlapur? That’s completely unrealistic.”

The proposal has also drawn sharp criticism online. Devesh Tiwari posted on X (formerly Twitter), “This is a stupid plan. It will create horrible bottlenecks at terminal stations. Why can’t CR reduce headway to 120 or 90 seconds during peak hours? It’s simple tech, but there’s zero willpower to implement it.”

Another internet User @warrenbhai added posted on X “Changing and crossing FOBs will be a nightmare. A lot of us catch up on sleep during the long travel. That won’t be possible anymore.”

Another commuter, Kumar Saket, called the proposal the “joke of the month,” while Bharat Soni criticized what he termed the “Reel Minister” for making hollow promises, stating:

“What’s new in promising 3-min frequency? WR already does that. CR used to run locals every 5 minutes up to Kalyan. Try giving us 15-min services up to Kasara and Karjat—that would be actual progress.”

@smartkalyan7 posted on X “Instead of this jumlabazi, build a new line between Kalyan and Borivali. Thousands waste time commuting to the western suburbs via Dadar.”

Maharashtra

Sanjay Raut demands renaming Nagpur to ‘Deekshabhoomi’; sparks debate in Maha

Published

on

A political debate has emerged in Maharashtra following a proposal by Shiv Sena Uddhav Balasaheb Thackeray MP Sanjay Raut to rename the city of Nagpur as “Deekshabhoomi.”

Speaking to the media in Nagpur, Maharashtra Revenue Minister and Nagpur Guardian Minister Chandrashekhar Bawankule responded to the demand by stating that the global significance of Deekshabhoomi is already well known, regardless of Raut’s remarks.

Speaking to reporters in Mumbai, Raut on Friday stated that changing the city’s name would serve as a true tribute to B. R. Ambedkar, noting that Ambedkar’s historic social revolution began in Nagpur.

He challenged Maharashtra Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis—who hails from and represents Nagpur—to initiate an official proposal for the name change.

He added that if the state government brings forward such a proposal, Shiv Sena (UBT) and party chief Uddhav Thackeray would extend their full support.

According to Raut, Dr B R Ambedkar initiated his social revolution in Nagpur, making the renaming of the city after Deekshabhoomi a fitting tribute.

He claimed that Shiv Sena (UBT) chief Uddhav Thackeray had also made suggestions regarding this, adding that his party would support the move if Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis and the state government drafted a formal proposal.

Raut’s demand comes amid an ongoing political controversy over renaming Mumbai’s Dadar station as Chaityabhoomi.

Following confusion over whether the Dadar railway station or the Dadar Metro station was being renamed to Chaityabhoomi—which required a clarification from the Chief Minister’s Office he argued that rather than focusing solely on a smaller station, renaming an entire city like Nagpur to Deekshabhoomi would be a far greater honour to Dr Ambedkar’s legacy.

However, the Chief Minister’s Office (CMO) clarified that only the underground Metro Line 3 station is being renamed as Chaityabhoomi.

An initial official press release mistakenly stated that the Dadar railway station would be renamed, prompting a clarification from the Chief Minister’s Office (CMO) to prevent public confusion and political pushback.

During the same press interaction, Raut also criticised the state government over delays and rising costs associated with the construction of the Babasaheb Ambedkar memorial at Indu Mill in Mumbai.

Meanwhile, Minister Bawankule noted that Nagpur’s Deekshabhoomi—the sacred monument of Navayana Buddhism where Dr Ambedkar embraced Buddhism along with hundreds of thousands of followers on October 14, 1956—already enjoys international recognition.

“Every person visiting Nagpur visits Deekshabhoomi. Nagpur has established its global identity through the name of Deekshabhoomi, and the entire world knows its importance,” he stated, without committing to an official renaming proposal.

During the same media interaction, Bawankule reaffirmed the state government’s commitment to completing the B R Ambedkar Memorial at Mumbai’s Indu Mill compound.

He acknowledged that project costs have escalated and work faced temporary delays due to material shortages. However, he assured that the government has allocated the necessary funds and is working to finish the remaining construction promptly.

Continue Reading

Business

Maha CM stresses land management, farm productivity at NITI Aayog meeting

Published

on

Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis said on Friday said that long-term planning, proper land management, timely execution of infrastructure projects, and boosting agricultural productivity are vital to Maharashtra’s all-round development.

He added that the state government is actively implementing a range of development initiatives to achieve these goals.

He made the remarks during a review meeting on Maharashtra’s development projects at his official residence, held with NITI Aayog Vice Chairman Ashok Kumar Lahiri.

Thanking NITI Aayog, the Chief Minister noted that the think tank has consistently provided guidance and practical advice to the state, expressing hope for continued support going forward. He reiterated that the administration is working in mission mode to complete development works at a set pace.

During the meeting, special emphasis was placed on long-term planning for land acquisition. Lahiri urged authorities to resolve pending issues related to land acquisition, infrastructure, and agriculture on priority.

Observing that land development and sound management can generate substantial revenue, Lahiri emphasised acquiring land needed for future development projects in advance and managing it effectively.

Land available at lower costs today can become far more valuable in the future, he said, calling for an ambitious land acquisition policy framed with future generations in mind.

He also expressed satisfaction with the progress of the state government’s flagship Vadhavan Port project.

Earlier, CM Fadnavis presented the state’s long-term development roadmap—anchored around the goal of making Maharashtra a $5-trillion economy by 2047, aligned with Viksit Bharat 2047.

He further stated that the government has laid focus on developing Mumbai Metropolitan Region (MMR) into a major economic engine, with NITI Aayog partnering on the city-region growth strategy to scale MMR’s economy from $140 billion toward $300 billion by 2030 and $1 trillion long-term.

A special development plan under post-Naxal development initiatives is being implemented to turn Gadchiroli into India’s first major integrated steel hub, alongside investments in infrastructure, education, healthcare, and employment.

Continue Reading

Maharashtra

Prabhadevi anti-encroachment demolition drive halted after Maha Dy CM Shinde talks with Railway Minister Vaishnaw

Published

on

A major anti-encroachment demolition drive near Prabhadevi railway station on the Western line was on Friday abruptly halted following a direct phone call between Maharashtra Deputy Chief Minister Eknath Shinde and Union Railway Minister Ashwini Vaishnaw.

Western Railway had scheduled a two-day demolition drive on Thursday and Friday to clear 101 unauthorised structures situated on railway land on the west side of Prabhadevi station.

A demolition squad, accompanied by JCB excavators and a heavy police deployment, arrived at the site to execute the action.

The move triggered fierce protests from local residents, who demanded proper rehabilitation before any structures were razed.

Shiv Sena (UBT) leader Ajay Choudhari and Maharashtra Navnirman Sena (MNS) leader Bala Nandgaonkar joined the residents on the streets, attempting to halt the drive through urgent phone calls to authorities.

Despite the opposition, railway officials and police initially refused to back down. The standoff ended only after Dy CM Shinde intervened and spoke directly with Union Railway Minister Ashwini Vaishnaw. Urging an immediate stop to the demolition, he requested that further action be taken only after taking local residents into confidence.

Following the conversation, Minister Vaishnaw issued immediate orders to suspend the operation, prompting the JCBs and demolition teams to withdraw from the area.

Shinde explained that a joint meeting between the Slum Rehabilitation Authority (SRA), the State Housing Department, and the Railway Ministry had already taken place the previous week.

“I personally discussed this with Railway Minister Ashwini Vaishnaw during that meeting,” Shinde said.

“These residents have been living here for 50 to 60 years; they are not recent settlers. We must ensure their proper rehabilitation. Together, the Railway Department and the Housing Department will rehabilitate them. Accordingly, the Railways’ R&D wing and our SRA policy team jointly prepared a Detailed Project Report (DPR), and it was decided that no demolition should occur until the rehabilitation process is settled,” he said.

Expressing disappointment that railway officials still proceeded to the site despite the agreement, Shinde added, “I just spoke with Ashwini Vaishnaw and reminded him that this action shouldn’t happen given our prior understanding. He assured me that he would instruct his officials to stop the drive immediately.”

Continue Reading

Trending